Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres (1780-1867)
The present sheet is one of the largest and most ambitious of Ingres’s portrait groups, and bears a dedication to the artist’s close friend, the sculptor, medal engraver and collector Jacques Edouard Gatteaux (1788-1881). The two artists met as pensionnaires at the Académie de France in Rome, and became lifelong friends. An indication of the affection felt by Ingres for Gatteaux is seen in a letter written to him while Ingres was serving as Director of the Académie de France in the 1830’s: ‘There are few true friends like you; one is so lucky to have one of your good and loyal character, I have every confidence in you, I regard you as the most sincere of all those that I know in the world.’ Gatteaux became a major supporter of Ingres’s work, and assembled a superb collection of hisdrawings, numbering over one hundred works. Unfortunately, these were all lost in a fire in Gatteaux’s home at 41, rue de Lille in Paris, during the defeat of the Commune in 1871. In later years Edouard Gatteaux added to his collection, and at the end of his life bequeathed many works to several French museums. The present sheet, however, remained in the possession of his descendants until 1931.
The Gatteaux family owned a large country house in Neauphle, near Versailles, where Ingres often stayed as a guest in the 1820’s. He returned there after the death of his first wife Madeleine in 1849, and it was at this time that he produced the present family group. The Gatteaux Family is highly unusual in Ingres’s oeuvre, however, in being a retrospective group portrait, as well as in its method of composition. Using single portraits made at different times, with The Gatteaux Family Ingres has created a composite family group and placed the whole in an elegant interior setting.
Ingres has here assembled three engravings by Claude-Marie-François Dien, each after his own earlier portrait drawings, of Edouard Gatteaux, seated at the right of the composition, his father, the engraver and medallist Nicolas-Marie Gatteaux (1751-1832), seated at the left, and his mother Louise-Rosalie Gatteaux, née Anfrye (1761-1847), in the center. Printed on thin paper, these three engravings were carefully silhouetted and laid down by Ingres onto a much larger sheet, which he then overdrew in pencil in such a way that the seams between the different sheets of paper are hardly visible to the naked
eye.
Only the upper part of the figure of Edouard Gatteaux in this large sheet, however, is in the form of an engraving. To this bust-length print, Ingres has added, drawn in fine pencil, the lower half of his friend’s body. Also added by the artist in pencil, standing to the left of Edouard Gatteaux, is the figure of Paméla de Gardanne (1824-1860), the orphaned granddaughter of Nicolas-Marie Gatteaux. Raised in the Gatteaux household, she married the engineer Edouard Brame in 1846, and the present sheet eventually descended in the Brame family. Ingres also drew the interior setting, and, in the
background at the extreme left, the small figure of a woman in an adjoining room, who has been identified as Edouard Gatteaux’s cousin, a Mme. (Eugène?) Anfrye.
Ingres’s original drawings of M. and Mme. Gatteaux, drawn in 1828 and 1825, respectively, as well as a bust-length portrait drawing of their son Edouard, dated 1834, all belonged to Edouard Gatteaux and were destroyed in the fire in his home in 1871. Their appearance is recorded, however, in engravings made after them by Claude-Marie-François Dien in the 1830’s, as well as drawn copies of all three portraits by an unknown hand, which are now in the Louvre.
It is interesting to note that, in this large composite drawing of The Gatteaux Family, Ingres was creating an imaginary family group. In 1850, when the drawing was made, Nicolas-Marie Gatteaux had been dead for eighteen years and Louise-Rosalie Gatteaux for three, while Edouard Gatteaux, seen here as a young men, was aged sixty-two. The two drawn portraits of Paméla de Gardanne and Mme. Anfrye, however, would seem to correspond to their proper ages at the time the drawing was made.
While the upper part of Edouard Gatteaux in this group portrait is composed of the Dien engraving after Ingres’s lost bust-length portrait drawing of 1834, the lower half of the figure is an entirely new invention by the artist. (Ingres may, however, have referred to a three-quarter length portrait of Edouard Gatteaux, in a similar but not identical pose to
that seen in the present sheet, which is recorded in an engraving by Achille Réveil. Réveil’s engraving, dated 1851, shows Ingres’s friend seated at a table with his work tools before him, and may record a lost drawing of the same approximate date as the bust-length portrait of 1834. It appears that, for The Gatteaux Family, Ingres combined Dien’s bust-length engraving with an entirely new conception of the lower half of Gatteaux’s body, developed from that of the lost three-quarter length portrait drawing engraved by Réveil. This is further suggested by the existence of a preparatory pencil
study for the torso and costume of the seated figure of Edouard Gatteaux, similar in pose and detail to this drawing of The Gatteaux Family, in the collection of the Musée Ingres in Montauban. Also in the Musée Ingres is a half-length pencil study by the artist for the standing Paméla de Gardanne.
A preparatory study by Ingres for the entire composition of this large drawing of The Gatteaux Family, on several sheets of joined tracing paper, is also in the collection of the Musée Ingres in Montauban. This preparatory drawing shows the seated figures full-length, a concept Ingres abandoned in the final drawing, however.
Ingres produced only three other comparably large and complex, multifigured portrait group drawings, all dated much earlier in his career: The Forestier Family of 1806 in the Louvre, The Family of Lucien Bonaparte, dated 1815, in the Fogg Art Museum in Cambridge, and The Constantin Stamaty Family of 1818 in the Louvre. The present sheet is the last and largest of the four, and the most visually complex. This large drawing of The Gatteaux Family was reproduced as an engraving by Achille Réveil in 1851, the year after it was made. The engraving was included in Albert Magimel’s magisterial compendium of illustrations of Ingres’s work, the Oeuvres de J.A. Ingres, published in 1851, and it is likely that Ingres made the present sheet with the intention of having it reproduced for this publication. As Patricia Condon has recently
noted of the present sheet, ‘This drawing, done specifically for 1850 Magimel/Réveil publication of Ingres’ collected works, documents both Ingres’s connections to the [Gatteaux] family and his experimentation with unconventional techniques in the context of a highly visible publication.’
The present sheet has long been admired as one of Ingres’s most significant works on paper. Extensively published and widely exhibited since 1881, the drawing remained in the collection of the Gatteaux family and its descendants until 1931. As early as 1863 it was described by one writer as the finest drawing in the Gatteaux collection, ‘a marvelous work, the sight of which brings great pleasure.’ In 1932, The Gatteaux Family was acquired by the bibliophile and collector Douglas H. Gordon, Jr. (1902-1986), in whose collection it remained for over fifty years. A Baltimore attorney, Gordon is perhaps best known today for his collection of some 1,200 French Renaissance books, which he bequeathed to the University of Virginia. He published The Censoring of Diderot’s Encyclopédie and the Re-Established Text in 1947, and was awarded the
Legion of Honour by the French government in 1959. Gordon’s collection of drawings included works by Italian, Dutch, American and, above all, French and English artists. Some 215 drawings from the Gordon collection were bequeathed to the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts in 1986.
Engraved
By Achille Réveil, for Albert Magimel’s Oeuvres de J.A. Ingres, in 1851
Provenance
Edouard Gatteaux, Paris, until 1881, by descent to the husband of his nieceEdouard Brame, Paris, until 1888, by descent to his son
Paul Brame, Paris, until 1908, by descent
Mme Paul Brame, Paris, by descent
Henri Brame, Paris & Neauphle-le-Château
Galerie Hector Brame, Paris, by 1931
Galerie Paul Cassirer, Berlin, 1931
M. Knoedler & Co., New York, 1931, where acquired by
Dr. Douglas Huntly Gordon, Annapolis & Baltimore, Maryland, 1932 [Lugt 1130a]
Sale, London, Christie's, 6 July 1987, lot 55
Masataka Tomita, by February 1988, sold to
Jan Krugier and Marie-Anne Poniatowski, Geneva
His sale, London, Sothebys, From Goya to Picasso, Works from the Private Collection of Jan Krugier, 6 February 2014, lot 170
Stephen Ongpin, London
Private collection, United States
Exhibitions
Palais de Versailles, Exposition d'art rétrospectif, 1881, no. 190Paris, Grand-Palais, Galeries Georges Petit, Exposition centennale de l'art français 1800-1889, 1900, no. 1088
Paris, Galeries Georges Petit, Ingres, 1911, no. 165
Chambre Syndicale de la Curiosité et des Beaux-Arts, Ingres, 1921, no. 120
Münich, Ludwigs-Galerie, Romantische Malerei in Deutschland und Frankreich, 1931, no. 43
Springfield, Springfield Museum of Fine Arts, and New York, M. Knoedler & Co, David and Ingres, 1939-1940, no. 33
Cincinnati, Cincinnati Art Museum, The Place of David and Ingres in a century of French Paintings, 1940
San Francisco, California Palace of the Legion of Honor, 19th Century French Drawings, 1947, no. 18
Baltimore, Baltimore Museum of Art, From Ingres to Gauguin, French Nineteenth Century Paintings Owned in Maryland, 1951, no. 7
New York, Galerie Paul Rosenberg, Ingres in American Collections, 1961, no. 64
Maryland, University of Maryland, College Park, Art Department, Hommage à Baudelaire, 1968
Louisville, Kentucky, The J.B. Speed Art Museum, In Pursuit of Perfection: The Art of J.-A.-D. Ingres, 1983, no. 75
Berlin, Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin & Preussischer Kulturbesitz, Linie, Licht und Schatten. Meisterzeichnungen und Skulpturen der Sammlung Jan und Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, 1999, no. 71, p. 156
Venice, Peggy Guggenheim Collection, Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, The Timeless Eye. Master Drawings from the Jan and Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski Collection, 1999, no. 84
Madrid, Museo Thyssen-Bornemisza, Miradas sin Tiempo. Dibujos, Pinturas y Esculturas de la Coleccion Jan y Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, 2000, no. 98
Paris, Musée Jacquemart-André, La passion du dessin. Collection Jan et Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, 2002, no. 87
Vienna, Albertina Museum, Goya bis Picasso. Meisterwerke der Sammlung Jan Krugier und Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, 2005, no. 13
Munich, Kunsthalle der Hypo-Kulturstiftung, Das Ewige Auge - Von Rembrandt bis Picasso. Meisterwerke der Sammlung Jan Krugier und Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, 2007, no. 82
Edinburgh, Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art, Cut and Paste: 400 Years of Collage, 2019, p. 61, no. 15
Literature
Albert Magimel, Oeuvres de J.A.D. Ingres, Paris, 1851, no. 58Théophile Silvestre, Histoire des artistes vivants, Paris, 1856, p. 36
Gautier, Ingres, "L'artiste", Paris, 5th April 1857, p. 6
Jules Lecomte, Le Perron de Tortoni, Paris, 1863, p. 249
Olivier Merson and E. Bellier de la Chavignerie, Ingres, Paris, 1867, pp. 81, 113
Henri Delaborde, Ingres, Paris, 1870, no. 308
République française, Ministère de l'Instruction publique, des Cultes et des Beaux-Arts, Collection de 120 dessins, croquis et peintures de M. Ingres, classés et mis en ordre par son ami E. Gatteaux, reproduits en photographie par Ch. Marcille, photographe des Musées Nationaux, I, Paris, 1875, no. 49
Collection des 120 dessins, croquis et peintures de M. Ingres classés et mis en ordre par son ami Edouard Gatteaux, Paris, pl. 10
Exposition rétrospective de Versailles, "La Chronique des Arts et de la Curiosité", Paris, 20th August 1881, p. 225
Both de Tauzia, Musée National du Louvre, dessins, cartons, pastels, et miniatures des diverses écoles, exposés, depuis 1879, dans les salles du 1er étage, deuxième notice supplémentaire, Paris, 1888, p. 141
Henri Jouin, Musée de portraits d'artistes, Paris, 1888, p. 75
Henri Lapauze, Les dessins de J.A.D. Ingres du Musée de Montauban, Paris, 1901, p. 266
Henri Lapauze, Les dessins de J.A.D. Ingres, Paris, 1903, no. 26, ill. p. 1
Jérome Doucet, Les peintres français, Paris, 1906, p. 119
Henri Lapauze, Ingres, Paris, 1911, p. 286, ill. p. 429
Ein neuer Naturalismus? Eine Rundfrage des Kunstblatts, Das Kunstblatt, Potsdam, September 1922, ill. p. 386
H. Brame, Ingres et ses amis Gatteaux, pp. 16-17, ill. p. 16
Lili Froehlich-Bum, Ingres, Vienna & Leipzig, 1924, pl. 57
Louis Hourticq, Ingres, Paris, 1928, p. 100
Morton Dauwen Zabel, "The Portrait Methods of Ingres", Art and Archeology, Washington, October 1929, pp. 113, 116
Hans Eckstein, Romantische Malerei in Deutschland und Frankreich, in Kunst und Künstler, XXIX, 11, Berlin, 1931, ill. p. 442
Jacques Mathey, Sur quelques portraits dessinés : par Ingres ou ses élèves ?, in Bulletin de la Société de l'histoire de l'art français, Paris, 1932, pp. 197-198
Jacques Mathey, Ingres portraitiste des Gatteaux et de M. de Norvins, Gazette des Beaux-Arts, Paris, August 1933, no. 2, pl. 7
Walter Pach, Ingres, London & New York, 1939, illustrated p. 207;
John Lee Clarke, Jr, David and Ingres: The Classical Ideal, Art News, New York, 25th November 1939, p. 16;
James W. Lane, David and Ingres View in New York, Art News, New York, 6th January 1940, reproduced p. 7;
Hans Naef, Ingres und Cezanne als Bildnismaler, Werk, Winterthur, October 1946, reproduced p. 342;
Karl Scheffer, Ingres, Bern, 1947, reproduced pl. 43;
Claude Roger-Marx, Ingres, Lausanne, 1947, reproduced pl. 43;
Anthony Bertram, Ingres, London and New York, 1947, reproduced pl. XXXIV;
Jean Alazard, Ingres et l'Ingrisme, Paris, 1950, p. 107;
From Ingres to Gauguin, The Baltimore Museum of Art News, Baltimore, November, 1951, reproduced p. 5;
Adelyn D. Breeskin, From Maryland Collections : Brilliant Facets of French 19th Century Art, The Art Digest, New York, 15th November 1951, reproduced p. 11;
Daniel Ternois, Les dessins d'Ingres au Musée de Montauban, les portraits, Inventaire général des dessins des musées de province, III, Paris, 1959, no. 57;
Jean Sutherland Boggs, Portraits by Degas, Berkeley & Los Angeles, 1962, p. 13, reproduced pl. 26;
Hans Naef, Die Bildniszeichnungen von J.A.D. Ingres, Bern, 1977-1980, vol.II, pp. 234, 403, 492-3, 501-2, vol. III, pp. 83, 171-2 and vol. V, pp. 318-319, no. 417;
Picasso et la Photographie, (catalogue de l'exposition), Musée Picasso, Paris, 1995, reproduced p. 170;
U. Fleckner, Abbild und Abstraktion. Die Kunst des Porträts im Werk von J.A.D. Ingres, Berliner Schriften zur Kunst, Vol.V, Mainz, 1995, pp. 162ff;
Anne Baldassari, Picasso et la photographie: “À plus grande vitesse que les images”, exhibition catalogue, Paris, 1995, pp.163-171, fig. 136;
Alexander Dückers, ed., Linie, Licht und Schatten: Meisterzeichnungen und Skulpturen der Sammlung Jan und Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, exhib. cat., Berlin, 1999, pp.156-157, no.71 (entry by Sigrid Achenbach);
Philip Rylands, ed., The Timeless Eye: Master Drawings from the Jan and Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski Collection, exhib. cat., Venice, 1999, pp.182-183, no.84;
Tomàs Llorens, ed., Miradas sin tiempo: Dibujos, Pinturas y Esculturas de la Colección Jan y Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, exhib. cat., Madrid, 2000, pp.228-229, no.98 (entry by Sigrid Achenbach);
Klaus Albert Schröder and Christine Ekelhart, ed., Goya bis Picasso: Meisterwerke der Sammlung Jan Krugier und Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, exhibition catalogue, Vienna, 2005, pp.48-49, no.13 (entry by Sigrid Achenbach);
Patricia A. Condon, ‘Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres: The Politics of Friendship’, in Deborah J. Johnson and David Ogawa, ed., Seeing and Beyond: Essays on Eighteenth- to Twenty-First-Century Art in Honor of Kermit Champa, New York, 2006, p. 49;
Adrien Goetz, Ingres collages: Dessins d’Ingres du musée de Montauban, exhib. cat., Montauban and Strasbourg, 2005-2006, pp. 30-32;
Jean-Pierre Cuzin and Dimitri Salmon, Ingres: Regards croisés, exhibition catalogue, Paris, 2006, p. 225 (as lost);
Christiane Lange and Roger Diederen, ed., Das ewige Auge – Von Rembrandt bis Picasso: Meisterwerke aus der Sammlung Jan Krugier und Marie-Anne Krugier-Poniatowski, exhib. cat., Munich, 2007, pp. 180-181, no. 82 (entry by Sigrid Achenbach);
Jean-Pierre Cuzin et al, Ingres et les modernes, exhib. cat., Quebec and Montauban, 2009, p. 312;
Mark Evans and Lucie Page, “Full of truth and simply arranged”: Wilhelm von Kaulbach’s Portrait of the Amsler Family’, Master Drawings, Spring 2016, pp. 72-73, fig. 9;
New York, Sotheby’s, Impressionist and Modern Art Day Sale, 13 November 2018, p.190, under no. 201, fig. 1;
Patrick Elliott, Cut and Paste: 400 Years of Collage, exhib. cat., Edinburgh, 2019, p. 61, no. 15.